If you want a sparkly lip gloss, use sparkly lipstick. The more lipstick you add, the more opaque your lip gloss will be. Some people find that the moisturizing kind of lipstick is easier to blend than the regular kind. Alternatively, try using eyeshadow to make a lip tint. [1] X Expert Source Nini Efia YangMakeup Artist Expert Interview. 27 August 2019.

If the lip gloss is not dark enough, add more lipstick. If the lip gloss is too dark, add more Vaseline.

Tiny jars meant for storing beads Tiny jars meant for storing paint Contact lens cases Pill boxes with tight-fitting lids

Just keep in mind this lip gloss won’t hold very long, so you’ll need to touch it up more frequently than regular lipstick. [5] X Expert Source Nini Efia YangMakeup Artist Expert Interview. 27 August 2019.

You do not need to use the Vaseline brand. You can use just about any type of petroleum jelly, as long as it is plain and unscented.

Don’t worry if the lip gloss is too gooey and liquid-y. It will become more firm as it cools.

If you’d like a shimmery lip gloss, use shimmery lipstick.

If you are using almond oil, start with 2 to 3 drops. [10] X Research source If you are using coconut oil, start with ¼ teaspoon of coconut oil per 2 tablespoons of Vaseline.

3 to 5 drops of candy flavoring will give the lip gloss a nice, subtle flavor. [11] X Research source A few drops of peppermint extract will give the lip gloss more flavor. You can also use vanilla extract instead. Fruity flavors like cherry are always nice for lips, too. [12] X Expert Source Shara StrandMakeup Artist Expert Interview. 14 April 2020. A sprinkle of cosmetic-grade glitter will give your lip gloss some sparkle. Do not use crafting glitter; even the scrapbooking kind is too thick.

Tiny jars meant for storing beads Tiny jars meant for storing paint Contact lens cases Pill boxes with tight-fitting lids

Once the lip gloss hardens, you can take it out of the fridge and use it. You don’t have to keep it in the fridge any more.